Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Tea Leaves

The Ceridian-UCLA Pulse of Commerce Index uses real time purchase volumes for diesel fuel as a proxy for over-the-road trucking volumes, which in turn relate to the volume of goods-in-process and final goods moving to distributors and retailers. According to the latest publication, the consecutive monthly declines for August and September have not been seen since 2009 and suggest that the economic momentum for inventory rebuilding has come to an end. The performance of this index is said to lead turns in the Federal Reserve's Index of Industrial Production. While we haven't worked with this Index directly, we have tried to use diesel fuel volumes as an indicator before, but never had the data that Ceridian can generate by providing financial services to volume purchasers. It's not a good sign.

At the same time, a friend who is in the market for rail cars indicates that cars are, and have been, coming out of mothballs, which is a positive for the rail car mode. Rail cars are associated more with movements of fuels, grains, fertilizers, chemicals and agricultural commodities. What he's seeing correlates well with the movement in grain prices, and it seems to be also related to growing export demand, despite the grousing about currencies. The problem with this indicator is that is seemingly more contemporaneous than leading. We'll have to wait and see, but the great results reported by Cargill yesterday reflect strength in the types of commodities that ship by rail, and to a lesser extent trucks.

Finally, the European Central Bank has published a paper by de Bondt, Maddaloni et al. that surveys the relationship between low rates in the run up to the financial system collapse, and it suggests that central banks may again be keeping rates too low for too long. The Fed is due to make more august pronouncements this week, and it may have painted itself into a corner. Backing away from the low rate commitment is off the table, especially given the pending mid-term elections. However, it is a very reasonable question to ask, namely the diminishing power of monetary policy to effect a meaningful boost of adrenalin to the economy going forward.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Duelling Pundits

It's one thing to have sports commentators or journalists talking over each other on the air. That's like bear baiting at the Globe Theater: an uncivilized sideshow. I can't remember anything like the daily spectacle of Federal Reserve Bank Presidents talking over each other in speeches and press releases. This practice should be reined in because it's unseemly and disconcerting. The Fed is in danger of being trivialized.

Dallas Federal Reserve Bank President Richard Fisher gave a good speech at the Economic Club of Minnesota. It covers quite a few points we've made before about the huge liquidity trap resulting from the unprecedented "quantitative easing." He quoted a statistic that is from the classic central banker paradigm: member banks at the Fed are holding more than $1 trillion in excess reserves with the central bank! I have an idea to mop these up. Do like the gift card issuing banks do with consumers: make the excess reserve balances decline monthly at a 2% annual rate. In other words, use 'em or lose 'em.

In Fisher's conversations with small business leaders, he says access to credit is rarely their number one concern. Interesting, and surprising too.

Aside from share buybacks and dividend increases, big company leaders have told Fisher that they don't see the case for investing in capital beyond their depreciation, and the biggest factor is uncertainty about the political situation and the subsequent roll out of regulations from health care reform and financial system reform. This makes some sense, but it also makes the global executives seem to be indecisive leaders.

The upshot of Fisher's speech is that additional expansionary policies by the Fed would be "pushing on a string," and that's something that we've said for a long time. He is one of the few Fed Presidents to really put the onus on fiscal policy going forward as a key to relieving the angst felt by big company executives.

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Choking on Disclosure

The newsletter Compliance Week reported on a symposium of general counsels, risk and compliance officers from a variety of public companies, mainly mid to large cap companies. These officers generally felt overwhelmed with the current and evolving structure of disclosures and filing regulations. Having gone through SOX as a first generation, accelerated filer, I can speak personally about the pressures this Act put on a small, efficient finance and accounting function. The people in the CW Symposium have very large staffs and access to sizable outside resources, and they feel overwhelmed!

They also felt that their boards had been forced into a checklist mentality, which has taken them away from their most important function which is to formulate, implement and monitor the company's strategic growth initiatives.

The example of the new SEC disclosures on climate risk is cited as an egregious example of regulation without purpose or value. Responsible scientists globally have a difficult time quantifying what climate change is, let alone "climate risk." Take this down to the level of an individual corporation: the concept of a corporation being able to describe or measure the effects of its actions on its incremental climate risk is laughable. Nevertheless, trees will be felled, paper wasted, and expensive lawyers will draft opaque prose that meets the standard, but which also will be glossed over by institutional investors for whom this provides no guidance on whether or not to buy or sell shares.

Ken Jones, the Chief Compliance Officer of Huron Consulting said, "We spend three times as much money...on executive compensation reporting than we did two years ago." This is a CAGR of 73%! The Dodd-Frank bill will add considerable complexity to the already foggy bog of executive compensation reporting.

To be fair, there's another side to the executive compensation issue. The previous disclosure was woeful, and in light of egregious practices that came out during the financial meltdown, it was clear that this was, and is, a serious issue of misappropriation of shareholder funds as well as an issue of economic rent capture. Since nothing substantive was achieved to address the fundamental issues that Rakesh Khurana has so clearly identified for so long, it was inevitable that a crushing set of regulations, yet to be implemented through rules, would emerge from the vacuum.

What about smaller public companies, which is where I have served as a CFO and a board member? Kevin Fry, the general counsel of PACCAR, said "You can't be a little public company anymore." That is not good for economic vitality.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

VW Loses Its Way

VW is shaking up its top executive management and changing its strategy to focus on the American market, and it couldn't come at a worse moment. The North American market is probably permanently downshifting to a lower level of sales, and it is narrowing the mass market segment, while also increasing segmentation in the luxury segment.

VW's always had wonderful, German characteristics: tight, precise steering; great brakes; a good front suspension; reliable gearbox and short throws, to name a few. Plus, they were economical and flat-out, fun to drive. My last VW, a German-built diesel got 50 mpg in New York City driving in the eighties and cost me nothing to maintain.

Now comes the news that they are going to "Americanize" the car. Big mistake. They were so close to having the right car in the Jetta, which had Rabbit-like performance in a big, comfortable sedan. They never got it quite right, but they were very close. They should go over the finish line with the Jetta platform. Apparently, it's back to the drawing board, and I don't think it will work. We have Saturns, Hyundais, Accords, Camrys, Nissans and Mazdas. Another me-too model won't work, and without the Teutonic flavor, VW will lose all its distinctiveness.

Some consumers regarded VW higher-end Jettas as BMW for the Ordinary Joe. Now their cup of Joe is going to become a cup of Sanka. Too bad.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Marketing an Accent and Coming Clean

BBC America runs a funny series of commercials about how British accents elevate the receptivity of the audience to a character, and their good example is Patrick Stewart as Captain Picard on Star Trek. I definitely would take him more seriously than Captain Kirk!

I was in a Minneapolis restroom looking to dry my hands, and I came upon a new hand dryer that was different from the ubiquitous down spouted, hot air blowers we've all seen. This one was made of a familiar grey plastic, and was dubbed an "Air Blade" dryer or some such name. It was made by Dyson, the company that has made a fortune selling bagless vacuum cleaners that "never lose their suction." More on this later.

The Dyson dryer was said to be more efficient at drying and more sanitary than wiping your hands. You put your hands together, fingers pointing down, into a slit-type opening and air dries your hands. I couldn't see the difference compared to the old, Edsel-style dryers. Dyson's great advertisements feature its very studious, well coiffed founder speaking in a great British accent. The first time I heard him, I ran out and bought the first Dyson vacuum cleaner. After all, he was an engineer, an innovative problem solver, and he personally hated vacuums that lost their suction, just as I did! What could be better? He had my implicit trust, and the accent was key.

This wasn't David Orek, who sounds like a carnival side showman, lifting bowling balls with his little vacuum cleaner. Dyson had size, design, plastic, and style.

Where am I going with this? One of Dyson's messages is that it solves the important problems, like unsanitary conditions from poor hand washing and vacuum cleaners that clog and lose suction. A recent Mayo Clinic study looked at hand washing in public facilities and found no relation between the use of towels versus the use of air dryers and better sanitation. The important variable in reducing germs and improving sanitation was technique in washing and time spent drying. Spend the right amount of time, and good old, brown paper towels are just fine. So, Dyson didn't solve a problem that was specific to the drying medium (towels), but it might have fed our own laziness that we'd rather have blown air than our own muscle power to dry our hands. Not to mention that lower waste from towels is offset to some extent by the constant repair and replacement of the air units, in addition to their energy costs. To paraphrase Alexander Graham Bell, "What have we (sic) wrought?"

Finally, as I sit here cleaning out my Dyson vacuum , I can come clean. Yes, the vacuum cleaner has no bag, and therefore it cannot lose suction from a full bag or a blocked filter. However, it does lose suction, often and unpredictably. There are some vents in the cyclone housing that clog up easily with lint or dust. Once these are blocked, the Dyson, cyclonic moving air mechanism comes to a halt and nothing is picked up. Yes, they got rid of the bag problem, but they substituted another problem, which is really the same issue. I really wanted to believe Jim Dyson, I really did, but he wasn't honest with me or millions of other consumers.

He really does make the best commercials though, and he has that great accent.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

GE CEO on Energy Policy

GE CEO Jeff Immelt is quoted at the Gridwise Global Forum, "This is a great country. But, you know, we have to have an energy policy. This is just stupid what we have today." I hope that he doesn't apologize later for his remarks, and I also hope that his refreshing candor stimulates some response from his fellow CEO's who either produce or use energy, which is pretty much every company.

In talking about clean energy and reduced greenhouse gas emissions, it is difficult to conceive of meeting any environmental goals without having a place for nuclear energy. In this respect, it is curious that we always cling to European examples when we bemoan our own health care industry. Yet, we ignore the European model when it comes to nuclear energy. Almost 80% of French electricity is generated by nuclear power. Wind and ethanol won't make a meaningful difference to the total energy demand in the U.S. for the foreseeable future. While coal is abundant, the problems with cleaning the coal and then sequestering CO2 byproducts are expensive, technologically challenging and potentially very harmful to the environment. Granted that GE is talking its book to some extent, given its leadership in nuclear power, but we applaud Mr. Immelt's taking the discussion to the public forum in a decisive fashion.

He did say something that might be confusing for GE shareholders, and that is that he no longer sees GE as being exclusively a purveyor of high end, expensive products in its market segments. Rather, in the future, he wants to have "the value product all the way up to the high end product" in every segment, to keep out the Indian and Chinese competition. I think this is both bad strategy and bad economics. If Indian and Chinese companies can, for example, produce low price, low margin, low tech consumer appliances for their own markets, then why not let them? This is the law of comparative advantage. If GE can bring to bear innovation, technology, and high quality manufacturing for demanding customers in any country, why not focus on this? Over time, it will be interesting to learn what he meant by this remark.

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

The Feeling's Mutual

As institutional shareholders have rightly been crying aloud for proxy access to submit their candidates for corporate director positions, the position of those institutional shareholders that are mutual fund management companies needs to be examined.

Wall Street and Main Street intersect in Mutual Fund Square. 90 million Americans are said to hold mutual fund investments, either in individual or retirement plan accounts. Carolyn McPhillips notes that mutual fund ownership is the "primary means by which individual investors participate in the financial markets." Institutional investors control about 70% of the shares traded on exchanges, according to John Bogle. Have you ever read the annual report of your mutual fund(s)? Have you ever looked at your fund's trustees? If I recognize 5% of the trustees, that would be a stretch. Many are attorneys at obscure law firms and it's completely unclear what qualifies them to be a trustee. Hopefully, as with corporate directors, we may see some explanation for why the boards are populated as they are.

Since funds have "unitary boards." which oversee five or more mutual funds in a family, a "nod your head Yes" director affects a large volume of assets. Although the Dodd-Frank bill has paid lip service to proxy access for mutual fund issuers, it will be exceedingly difficult for shareholders to make significant changes. Does this matter? It sure does.

The governance of mutual fund companies, with exceptions such as Vanguard and Dodge & Cox, does not meet the standards of transparency, disclosure, and shareholder friendliness that are being imposed on corporate issuers. If governance were to improve, then over time, one would expect fewer duplicative fund offerings, elimination of multiple share classes, lower fees, and better performance. That would be nice for those 90 million of us who are owners of mutual funds.