Friday, January 21, 2011

A Capital Spending Boom?

My former colleague, Alliance Bernstein U.S. Economist Joe Carson's current Perspectives bulletin notes some interesting harbingers of a U.S. economic recovery that will look different from previous recoveries in our business cycle history.

In previous cycles over the past fifty years, the annualized rate of recovery in real GDP six quarters after the cycle trough has been about 5.5%, of which 3.6% came from recoveries in housing and in personal consumption expenditures. ("New Mix Growth Story is Intact, 1/21/2011) Growth in investment and exports generated 1.9% annualized on average.

The current upturn's rate is 5.1%, which is comparable to the historical average, but the composition of contributors to growth is quite different, according to Carson's analysis. In the current upturn, 3.2% at an annualized rate over six quarters is coming from investment and exports, more than double the historical average rate. This is quite striking.

U.S. merchandise exports are going to emerging markets, versus a declining trend of export shipments to developed markets. "In our view, U.S. manufacturers will increasingly realize that they must upgrade their aging capital stock to maintain their competitive edge globally and boost production." This is music to our ears! Less financial engineering and more fundamental investment with the huge cash hoard of Corporate America.

He cites examples of Union Pacific Railroad, Intel and Ford Motor, all of which have publicly announced plans to increase capital spending by 25% in their network, build a new fab in Oregon, and build a new transit van plant in Missouri, respectively.

What if we were to scrap the current tax system: simplify it, get rid of outmoded deductions, lower rates and broaden the base? Add these and other fundamental improvements, like training our workforce, and you have a real reason for stock market valuations to start higher.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

What Do We Want China To Do?

I was impressed by the way Chinese President Hu worked the line of dignitaries at the White House before the formal meetings with President Obama. He looked relaxed, engaged, and comfortable shaking hands, and he seemed genuinely pleased to see Vice President Biden. Depending on the day, President Obama looked pensive, relaxed, stressed and confused.

We are not going to talk down the Chinese currency. Decades ago, this was called "jawboning,' and it didn't work under President Nixon and it won't work now. The Chinese will not make any significant efforts to move off their policy. Let's save a few trees and stop writing or talking about this.

Now, we trot out our business leaders with various special pleadings for their industries. Ladies and gentlemen, please go back to your offices and work on your businesses. Software piracy and intellectual property issues are real issues now, and they cast a pall over future economic relations. Going back to the days of Microsoft Office and Lotus installations on diskettes, there were all kinds of protections, in the form of keys, to prevent multiple installations and copying of the applications. There were also widely available $20 key breakers for sale on the street that unlocked these applications. I'm not sure that the solutions to illegal downloads can be strictly technological, as the hackers are now unconstrained and more clever than the corporate code writers. Unless the Chinese become convinced that it is in their long run interest to become a part of the global institutional system around organizations like WIPO, there is little hope here.

On the other hand, noise about making other currencies the basis for global trade is, for the medium term future, just posturing, as analysis by Professor Peter Kenen and others have argued. We shouldn't get exercised by this.

American companies doing business in China will have to do it on their terms, not ours, no matter what the final communique from the White House says. Carving out a stake in their market will ultimately involve loss of control over partnerships and joint ventures, and impacts on the brands. The companies will just have to quantify what these trade offs are worth and factor it into the NPV of the whole investment project. Wishing is not going to change anything here either.

We have to take the initiative on things we can control: our fiscal lack of discipline, our perpetual list of subsidies and ineffective social programs, the bloated, inefficient and unfocused structure of our public and private universities, the technical training of our workforce, the rediscovery of our manufacturing heritage, and shrinking of the risk in our increasingly concentrated financial sector. If we did any of these things, you can believe that the Chinese leadership would sit up and take notice.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

State Pensions Funds: Bad Moon Rising?

Donald J. Boyd of the Rockefeller Institute of Government is quoted in today's New York Times on the huge losses in state pension funds, "It is truly astounding. They ($477 billion in losses) don't translate immediately into budgetary stress for states. But what does happen is through the wizardry of actuarial valuations, they will drive pension contributions by states and localities up considerably in the coming years, and that's true despite the good stock market of 2009, and the relatively good stock market of 2010."

His characterization omits something important. Localities have already felt this pain through problems with the retirement plans for police and firefighters. State laws call for the cities to make up shortfalls, and in my city, the cost of this shortfall has already been borne by the taxpayers. Our City's problem is now sitting invisible to all except career government insiders at the State level, where it will be papered over with propaganda about public employees being scapegoats. The New York Times story lays out the issue with state pension fund shortfalls well. My issue comes from reading the Conference Board's "2010 Institutional Investment Report," which covers 2009 data.

In the early stages of the financial crisis we read many stories about states and municipalities creating problems for themselves by buying auction-rate securities, which promised above money market returns with no additional risk. Of course, these were unsuitable investments for the clients pushed on to them by unscrupulous brokers. City managers and state officials later filed suit whining that they never understood the risks of what they were buying.

The Conference Board report notes, "....many of these (hedge fund) investments are not publicly traded and lack an efficient quotation system. As a result, the value of alternative asset classes, as represented at the end of 2009, might not yet fully reflect the losses incurred by the public market during the 2008 financial crisis."

Among the Top 10 defined benefit plans ranked by the level of hedge fund investments at year-end 2009, fully 8 are public plans! As a percent of defined benefit assets, they are:
  • Pennsylvania Retirement (12.8%)
  • California Public Employees Retirement (2.8%)
  • Massachusetts PRIM (10.9%)
  • Pennsylvania Public School Employees (7.6%)
  • Virginia Retirement (7.2%)
  • New Jersey (4.3%)
  • New York State Common Fund (2.3%)
  • University of California (6%)

Going way down the list of the Top 200, one finds the Missouri State Employees Fund with 25% of their assets in hedge funds. I wonder what their board of trustees talks about? Another small detail is that Pennsylvania Retirement and Massachusetts PRIM have the bulk of their hedge fund assets in the "fund of funds" category which are expensive and more fraught with valuation and liquidity issues.

Hedge funds certainly have their place, and most of the top Ivy League endowment funds have used them very effectively in meeting the budgetary needs of their institutions, for which the endowments often provide as much as a third of the annual operating budget. However, these plans have access to the best funds, the best managers, and the best pricing. Their business school faculties, as at Yale, Dartmouth and others provide tremendous analytical horsepower to the internal management teams. They also have influential and knowledgeable alumni oversight from the financial services industry. In this context, the asset class makes perfect sense. For state and public employee retirement plans, I would say they are another set of land mines that deserve more transparency and public scrutiny, and we shouldn't pass the problem on to the general taxpayers. On that point, as John Fogerty writes, "I see trouble on the way."

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Long Term Forecasts: Often Wrong, Never in Doubt

Think back to the middle years of the "Japanese Economic Miracle." American consumers were buying Japanese-made cars by the millions, first made in Japan, then made in Fremont and Marysville. Japanese banks were getting into equity research and investment banking. Japanese companies were buying trophy American real estate, like Rockefeller Center. We were all going to work for Japan, Inc. That forecast was outrun by reality.

The Japanese auto industry made its mark, and it made some smart moves by taking minority stakes in future manufacturing leaders like Hyundai. Eventually, however, companies like Toyota got too big and lost their way. They are entering the inevitable adjustment period. Japanese investment banks lost hundreds of millions of dollars, and they never took their places at the table of the Wall Street elite. Much of the real estate was bought at the absolute top of the market, and the buyers got whipsawed into selling near the bottom. Global economics and currencies forced adjustments that destroyed any myths about Japan, Inc. Political, social and demographic issues, forgotten by most quantitative forecasters, led to a Lost Decade.

Fast forward to the current forecasts about the Chinese economic juggernaut. The capitalist enterprise in China is growing up in a Wild West atmosphere, unfettered by economic, financial, legal or environmental regulation. Our western gold rush eventually turned into fools gold. We see occasional reports about homeless Chinese construction workers building Olympic venues, major health and pollution problems in the countryside, a forgotten prison population, and a central government that blithely believes it will forever keep the genie of political and social change in the lamp.

Martin Feldstein, not usually optimistic about economic trends, writes about self-corrective, economic mechanisms at work in adjusting the global savings-investment imbalance. He believes that we will see an increase in both U.S. private and government savings, the latter being driven by increased fiscal responsibility in future budgets. Feldstein also sees rising Chinese consumption, both public and private, driven by both income effects and by a real appreciation of the renminbi, which he estimates is already rising at a nine percent annual rate.

He estimates that a potential rise in the US savings rate to 7 percent of GDP, which after absorbing some of this to increasing fixed investment, would leave enough to reduce the current account deficit to about 1 percent of GDP without any large government regulatory changes. He could very well be overly optimistic, but it doesn't seem unreasonable.

If we as a nation were to to invest in rebuilding our manufacturing base into an efficient machine by global standards, and improve the productivity and training of our work force, then we could reap significant benefit from these medium to long-term adjustments. Forget those long-term forecasts, and Happy New Year!

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

What Did Ben Bernanke Say?

Commentators are hyperventilating about the Fed Chairman's apparently contradictory statements about the potentially inflationary impacts of QE2. Since Mr. Bernanke is now a full-fledged political figure, contradictory statements and a lack of clarity are basic tools in the sound bite arsenal.

He said that the effect of QE2 was not to increase currency in circulation, and therefore there was no need to worry about inflationary expectations increasing. This may be correct, but it is off the point and misleading. The unprecedented expansion of the Fed's balance sheet has not increased the amount of currency in the hands of the nonbank public. True enough.

However, the truth is that nobody really knows the effect of such a huge expansion of the monetary base on inflationary expectations. Historically, the impacts of other such expansions in foreign countries is mixed. Generally, if the expansion is viewed as temporary, and market participants believe that imbalances will be redressed in our case by fiscal policy restraints and budget balancing, then the expansion will serve its limited purpose and not have an inflationary effect. However, there is no reason to believe that our politicians will show any fiscal leadership or restraint. Where is the experience to show that they can rise to the occasion?

If the monetary base expansion is viewed as permanent, then it will almost certainly lead to higher inflationary expectations, and we will be in uncharted territory..again.

Boone Pickens: The Wind Dies Down

From today's Wall Street Journal, "The Dallas-based entrepreneur, who has relentlessly promoted his "Pickens Plan" since July 4, 2008, announced earlier this month that he's abandoning the wind business to focus on natural gas."

"Two years ago, natural gas prices were spiking and Mr. Pickens figured they'd stay high. He placed a $2 billion order for wind turbines with General Electric. Shortly afterward, he began selling the Pickens Plan. The United States, he claimed, is "the Saudi Arabia of wind," and wind energy is an essential part of the cure for the curse of imported oil. " There's nothing like a Texan hyping energy--except that Mr. Pickens didn't understand very much about wind as an energy source nor about relative prices.

Wind may have a minor role to play in a US energy portfolio, but for all the ancillary investment in grid connectivity, storage issues and the sheer visual and auditory blight of the towers, it is clear that natural gas and nuclear can have bigger impacts on curbing greenhouse gas emissions than wind ever will. Increasing fleet efficiency for cars and trucks, and cutting commercial and residential energy use are also ready channels for reducing electricity demand growth and hence the need for new plants, which means less greenhouse gas emissions than the current baseline trends.

Monday, December 20, 2010

An Unrepentant Financial Sector

What's wrong with the economic picture as we get to the end of 2010? There's a wide divergence of opinions about inflationary expectations. Looking at economic statistics, we don't see where non-monetary, demand-induced inflation is going to originate. We've always looked at the core inflation statistics, namely excluding food and energy prices. However, research from the Cleveland Fed has shown that focusing on this series alone reduces the power of inflation forecasts. Its Median CPI, or trimmed CPI, shows inflation rates on a trailing twelve month basis at 0.5%. Taking their approach to extract the forecasts embedded in financial asset prices, they come up with an expectation of 1.5%. Again, there are no alarm signals here.

Yet, the Treasury market has really tanked in December, and it's been reflected in the breathtaking drops in some of the best known bond mutual funds, including Pimco Total Return and Harbor Bond, also advised by Pimco. Both funds employ the "shake hands with the Government strategy" taken early in the crisis by Pimco, and consequently both funds are replete with government obligations. In some measure, though, this is the reversal of a few weeks ago when Treasuries rocketed in the wake of the Irish debt crisis and a flight out of the Euro. This latest move down is seen as a signal of higher expected inflation, but it seems hard to read higher inflation in the tea leaves based on this latest move in bond funds.

So, we believe there is almost no pricing power for manufacturers in the face of diminished consumer interest and limited consumer buying power in developed markets, apart from those consumers buying Louis Vuitton (lawyers, investment bankers and Keith Richards). The financial sector is virtually unaffected post-crisis, and there is even some optimism for near-comatose patients like Citi. The Financial Reform Commission has been an abject failure, and both parties are supplying duelling narratives about what caused the crisis.

In the meantime, on the real side, companies remain flush with cash and there is talk about a strong M&A market in 2011, probably driven by foreign buyers in US and European markets. There is precious little investment in new manufacturing capacity to pursue future growth in profits and employment. Share buybacks get the CEO's headlines, and not investing in the core businesses.

We've said this for almost three years now, but until the financial sector stops wagging the dog and the US manufacturing sector reinvents itself, it's difficult to imagine what will drive a durable recovery, a reduction in unemployment or a meaningful acceleration of inflation.