Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Corporate Welfare for Bank Investors: Paulson's Gift

The current week's stock market meltdown took me back to October 13th, 2008 when then Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson summoned the CEO's of ten leading banks to an emergency meeting in Washington, D.C. The worst weekly decline in stock market history, to that time, precipitated the meeting.


Pietro Veronesi and Luigi Zingales of the U of Chicago Booth School of Business wrote a paper, "Paulson's Gift," which is a well reasoned analysis of the net benefits to society of the plan to inject $125 billion of preferred equity into the nation's top banks, as well as providing them with extremely valuable financial guarantees.


The lack of a rapid resolution authority for these SIFIs (Strategically Important Financial Institutions) and the desperate condition of Citigroup and the former investment banks, including Paulson's own Goldman Sachs forced an emergency plan that was "very expensive for taxpayers."


In a creative use of CDS rates, the authors generated a Fama analysis of the news events disclosing the investment and its impact on the value of the investment claims for the ten bank holding companies. For the intervention to have social value, it had to accomplish something which the market could not do, while providing a net social benefit to taxpayers.


Bank bond holders made out the best from the taxpayer handouts. The value of their holdings, the authors estimate, increased by $120.5 billion between October 10-October 14, 2008. Bank equity holders overall lost $2.8 billion, with JP Morgan Chase stock holders losing $34 billion, while shareholders of Citigroup and Goldman Sachs gained $8 billion each from taxpayer largess.


Preferred equity value rose by $6.7 billion. The value of derivative contracts increased by $5.3 billion.


Taxpayers might have made a small, risk unadjusted gain on the preferred equity investment and attached warrants, but the granting of a three year FDIC guarantee on all new, unsecured bank debt issued by the ten banks before June 2009 and an extension of FDIC insurance to all non-interest bearing deposits, swung a small benefit to a cost of $21 to $44 billion, according to the paper. Champagne corks must have been popping on Wall Street.


The authors, Charles Calomiris and others have proposed various automatic mechanisms for debt-equity swaps which economically dominate the Paulson plan. However, we've done nothing with the bankruptcy laws, nor have we created any special resolution authority for SIFI's that might avoid similar problems in the future.


As the authors point out, "the pressure for governments to intervene is irresistible," and now banks know that they are permanently backstopped for injudicious risk taking. Let's hope that we don't have any similar, daffy ideas coming out of this week's stock market decline.
































Monday, August 8, 2011

Treasury Note Yields At New Lows

It seemed to us in July, that Treasuries would continue to be a safe haven for investors after any downgrade, and today's news confirms this. The Wall Street Journal writes that the two year Note's yield of 0.232% is a record low and below the top end of the Fed's policy band for the rate. The financial press seems to forget that safety and liquidity are very closely intertwined. Perhaps a Swiss government bond somewhere may be perceived as "safer," but Treasuries are the broadest, deepest and most liquid market for FI obligations, and that's important for nervous investors.

S&P, we can all agree, has imprudently overplayed their marketing hand and revealed, through their $2 trillion arithmetic error, that they don't deserve to be taken seriously on the U.S credit rating downgrade.

It was discouraging to read that the Justice Department has concluded its investigation into actions taken by Countrywide Financial and its officers during the run up to the financial crisis. Nobody has gone to jail yet, and it sounds as if that will continue to be the case. The Fairholme Fund's self-interested conference call with Bank of America management might be interesting, although it seems quite bizarre that the BofA management has agreed to this unique format for a 1% shareholder. It's a funny way to do business, in our opinion.

Friday, August 5, 2011

Inflation and the Fed

I don't know who said this, but I'll paraphrase: "An electorate gets the leadership it deserves." Well, the recent demonstration of legislative and Presidential brinkmanship about the debt ceiling certainly doesn't reflect well on we the people who elected them. The good news is that it could be worse. We could be the European electorate, who get whipsawed by their own national leaders and by both unelected bureaucrats in Brussels and a European Central Bank.

Let's go back to the early days of the financial crisis when it was being described as a crisis of liquidity. Well, the U.S. Federal Reserve unleashed a historically unprecedented global tsunami of liquidity. It had to be reflected in the markets for financial assets, and yet this basic economic insight has been pooh-poohed repeatedly.

Joseph Carson, U.S. Director of Global Research for Alliance Bernstein, writing in his August 5th letter notes, "Looking back, the Federal Reserve's second quantitative easing program (QE2) is partly to blame for the surge in commodity prices that has weighed on growth this year. Although several factors contributed to the sharp rise in oil prices, ....a sharp increase in commodity prices began to develop almost immediately after the Fed started QE2 last November."

There's really no fundamental inflationary pressure worldwide because of deficient aggregate demand compared to worldwide excess capacity in key industries, such as steel, natural gas, and aluminum to name a few. Much of this excess capacity has been built in China.

As a mirror to U.S. fiscal profligacy, there is the totally inefficient allocation of capital in the Chinese model of state capitalism. In a drive to build capacity for its own projected GDP growth rates of 10% per annum and to become a global exporter of industrial goods and machinery, China has invested heavily in basic materials like steel and aluminum. All of this activity has fed back into their commercial real estate bubble. Skyscrapers bigger than the Empire State Building were to have been built already, but like our "shovel ready" infrastructure projects, these projects are vacant lots. The stimulus loans for the projects have already been disbursed, and these loans, wherever they reside, are bad and unrecognized on public and private financial statements.

So, again, from the point of view of the real economy, it's almost impossible to pick up a real sniff of rising inflation trends, apart from what's being driven by the continuing misguided monetary policy. Monetary policy will also do nothing for global employment.

Mary Ellen Stanek, CFA the Chief Investment Officer for Robert W. Baird's Fixed Income funds wrote recently for her clients, "We are not seeing signs of worrisome inflation...while there are visible signs of inflation in food and energy, these pockets of inflation have not....worked their way into longer term inflation expectations in a meaningful way." If the bond market imposes inflationary discipline on issuers, then this opinion from a big, savvy player carries a lot of weight.

The stock market may be waking up to the fact that lots of liquid assets on the books of public corporation are nice to have, but in the long run deficient global aggregate demand and a zombie consumer sector with over leveraged households mean low unit growth and lack of pricing flexibility. Not great for earnings.

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Secretary Panetta: Cut Defense Procurement Budgets

Photo credit: J. Emilio Flores for the New York Times.

When the Panel of Wise People meets to eventually decide on $1.2 trillion of "spending reductions," they are to fall on defense and social expenditures. Let's not cut defense spending on our troops, as we continue to ask fewer and fewer troops to do so much more. When they come home, we don't keep up our end of the bargain with them either. Everybody knows that there is tremendous waste and duplication in the services competing with each other for their own fighters or bombers. Over the decades, we've done precious little of substance on this front.

Pictured above is the Air Force's $12 billion Global Hawk program prototype, designed to replace the long-serving U2, in which Colonel Gary Powers was shot down way back in the Cold War era. It looks almost like a battle ship with wings. With all the progress in miniaturizing digital video technologies to virtual commodities, and progress in making lighter, stronger materials, it seems to me that the concept of this aircraft is a throwback to days gone by. Can't we have a lot more, smaller, dispersed, lower-cost-per unit drones spread over a network? Can't a network of satellites do more functions at a lower cost?

Again, as our military troops on the ground have fallen victim to expensive, failed technologies like Swiss cheese armored vehicles in Afghanistan, I hope that we take a good hard look at DoD procurement programs for some of our recently mandated defense cuts in the coming year.

Monday, August 1, 2011

Put Some Chrome on Microsoft Explorer

A comment often made as to why Google still has the dominant share of U.S. search is the notion that "it's automatic," i.e. the default choice, the top of mind. Paradoxically, even though Internet Explorer still dominates Web browsing share, it does absolutely nothing to bring Bing to the top of mind. Google Chrome may have a somewhat too spartan look, but it seems work fast, and web pages compose themselves quickly, without the freezes and crashes that plague Explorer users. Firefox is, of course, another safe, crash-resistant alternative too.

Also, even though tabbed browsing is now commonplace, it seems to work a lot better in Google Chrome than it does in Explorer, which again seizes or freezes when too many tabs are open. Machine resources seem to get tied up faster in the Microsoft complex of Windows, IE, and Bing than they do without Internet Explorer in the mix.

It's probably way too costly and risky to expect that Microsoft would radically simplify the kernel of Explorer, but it should. It would require quite a paradigm shift in the way it deals with partner applications, but IE is still not an application worthy of a market leader.

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Microsoft Should Keep Searching

We've been reflecting on Microsoft since 2009, a company which often seems like a statistical value, but which often disappoints. Divesting its Bing search engine effort would be the worst thing Microsoft could do, both strategically and from the point of view of transforming investor perception of the company. Hedge fund managers and industry analysts are rightly frustrated with the deployment of the company's assets and its habit of always playing catch-up to innovators like Google.

Any buyer of Bing would not pay full value for the franchise, and to sell it to Facebook would be doubly foolish. Microsoft is an investor in Facebook, and it now has an alliance with the perceived leader in social media. Facebook sees itself as allied with one of the founders of the tech revolution, and it probably sees a good cultural fit with the "new Microsoft" groups like Bing. Why throw this away for a piddling amount of cash, which Microsoft doesn't need?

Even Google, the imposing Transformer, has stumbled a few times. Google Health shut down with little fanfare or recrimination. The government says that EMR's are the key to taking costs out of health care (they're wrong), and Google couldn't come up with a consumer friendly option. Google + (what a lousy name!) is playing catch up to Facebook--not an enviable position.

So, for Microsoft, it's time to put the past behind, and like smart shareholders, look at the future. As Credit Suisse's Phillip Winslow put it, Microsoft's Q4 featured "monster bookings" of unearned revenue amounting to $17.1 billion! Revenue growth was strong in Servers and Tools (+11.9%), Business (+7.5%), and Entertainment and Devices (+28.8%).

So, let's look at Online Services, which includes Bing. Winslow writes that the June quarter had an operating loss of $728 million, or almost $3 billion at an annualized run rate. Online advertising revenue of growth of 19% was less than Credit Suisse's estimate, and revenue per search was down. Think about two years ago, when Microsoft has a 7.2% share in U.S. search, which it has now doubled to 14.4%, and including its powering of Yahoo! search, it has a 27% share of the U.S. search market. This is nothing to sneeze at!

I don't know how Microsoft allocates costs and charges among its divisions, but the operating losses to Online Services probably includes expenses of building massive data centers that power Azure, which is one of Microsoft's cloud computing offerings which will be critical for expanding Service and Tools and the Business Divisions. So, it seems unlikely that the $3 billion annualized run rate of losses in Online Services is the search engine effort itself.

A minor point, but not to me, is that I actually like Bing as a search engine. I was one of the early guinea pigs for MSN Network, taking an MSN email before they acquired Hotmail. I know how lame and poorly conceived their products can be. Bing is very, very different in look, feel and performance: it's a more than acceptable substitute, with certain advantages, like its response to travel inquiries. Remember that Peter Lynch once, perhaps apocryphally, bought Dunkin' Donuts for Fidelity Magellan because he liked the coffee!

The New York Times Sunday article on Bing gives me the feeling that Microsoft has created a different sub-culture in the Bing strategic business unit. Qi Lu, the President of Online Services, is quoted saying his mission is to "change the game," while recognizing that it will be "a long-term journey." Dr. Lu also characterizes most Microsoft project leaders as having a "renters mentality," whereas winning in search means having a "homeowners mentality," which I take to mean being emotionally invested in their business, liking their neighborhood and meaning to stay for a long time. Indeed, the Times reports that's the promise that CEO Steve Ballmer made to the group as he assembled them. I also like the comment because it came not from the usual cliche spouting, Stanford MBA type but from a Carnegie Mellon computer science PhD. I think Dr. Lu believes what he says.

Which reminds me, what about China? This is the place where every business needs to be to succeed, goes the market patter. Well, in its haste to "do no evil" while also taking over the world, Google appears to be have burned some bridges in China. Microsoft's research lab in Beijing produced a key Bing team leader in Dr. Harry Shum, and it appears that Microsoft has wide-open options in overseas markets, including China and others. Microsoft's "Mango" Windows Phone 7.5 supports 17 new languages, according to Tim Carmody. Windows Mobile was less than stellar, so let's hope that they've invested in getting Mango right.

As industry analysts write, the mobile computing/telephone platforms will be the convergent battleground for really expanding and personalizing online advertising and target marketing. We're very likely to have a duopoly in this market, and were Microsoft to exit Bing, the second player would NOT be Microsoft, and this would be a tremendous loss for its shareholders.

Microsoft has integrated Bing into platforms like Xbox Live, which once seemed moribund but which is increasingly popular among twenty-something gamers. All of this multi-platform embedding of Bing takes investment, and now is not the time to take the ill-advised strategy of writing off the efforts. Microsoft, would among other things, break faith with some of its powerful new innovators inside the company, thereby dooming it to be regarded as a dinosaur in the tech world.

Microsoft should look at this issue like Warren Buffett looks at Berskhire's portfolio. Buffett's job is to reallocate cash flows from businesses which don't need them (like See's Candies) to businesses with significant moats and potential for high returns. For once, this appears to be what Microsoft has begun to do with search, in effect diverting large free cash flows from Office to ventures like Bing. Keep it up, Microsoft: don't blink here, and don't be waylaid by short-term concerns.

Friday, July 29, 2011

USA Men's Soccer Changes Its Leadership

U.S. Coach Bob Bradley was probably unfairly dismissed as US Soccer's Men's coach, precipitated by the team's dismal showing against Mexico, and with three years to go until the next World Cup. Jurgen Klinsmann, a talismanic striker who proved himself in the top leagues in Germany, Italy and England has taken the job, after turning it down once before.

The reason for his first refusal was instructive. He wanted total control over all U.S. Soccer operations. In our corporate model of organization, President Sunil Gulati couldn't create a position like this. Is Klinsmann a control freak or a megalomaniac? Not at all. He understands the U.S. issues all too well.

Bob Bradley, like all the U.S. coaches before him, didn't have a wealth of players to choose from to form a team which can compete at the highest international levels, plain and simple. Relatively few of our players go abroad to star in England, Germany, Italy or Spain. The MLS has improved its level of competition significantly, but it has diluted the domestic talent by expansion and by the occasional binges of importing over-the-hill foreign players.

The U.S. team has always suffered from a dearth of out and out strikers, who are not glorified midfielders. Clint Dempsey has proven to be a top class striker in the English Premier League, but on the U.S. squad he suffers for a good partner and for good service from the wings. Landon Donovan is a fine player who has turned into a good team leader, but he cannot carry the team on the field. The U.S. defense is aging and inconsistent. The midfield is a revolving door.

Our youth and Olympic Development Program are not well coached, well directed, and have not been a great feeder either for the league or the US team. Most of the youth teams that I seen and coached against are glorified "kick and rush" sides with iron lungs and great physicality. Occasionally, you see teams that pass to feet, pass backwards, switch sides and maintain possession, but these are rare. Very, very rarely do you see lethal strikers who can make a shot out of nothing. In other countries and leagues, they are common. Why?

Klinsmann, in his own words, has said publicly that the U.S. has not found its soccer identity and it may take years to do so. He cited our university system as being completely disassociated from professional player development, which is different from many countries. Klinsmann, because of his German pedigree from Stuttgart and Bayern Munich, has immaculate technique and great vision and field sense. Can he help the U.S. define its style? Can he work with limited talent, without the control over any of his feeder systems? His coaching tenure at Bayern Munich ended in mutual frustration after one year. I hope he does well for our country, and I think that Bob Bradley did a very fine job and fielded a team that wore our colors well.

.